Which Singapore Math series should I use?

Singapore Math is a rising trend in math education in schools and with homeschoolers, for the simple reason that it works. As an experienced Singapore Math teacher and trainer, I often get the question, “Which Singapore Math series should I use?” This question is posed by both teachers and homeschooling parents, and as more series enter the market, the choice becomes more challenging. In this article, I will present the pros and cons of each current series as I see them. Please feel free to contribute your views in the comments below.

Singapore Math, US Edition, published by Marshall-Cavendish:
This edition has been around the longest in the US. The main difference from the curriculum Singapore was using until recently is that this edition includes some additional problems using US measurements (feet, miles, pounds, etc.). This is the series that Singaporean students used when they scored highest on the TIMSS (international) test.

Pros: 

• Short, focused textbooks and workbooks.
• Clear graphics.
• Emphasis on mental math.
• Clear sequence from one book to the next.
• Follows the best of the Singaporean teaching model.
• Fits the Common Core State Standards well (see this article).
• Decent Homeschooling Guide, from what I hear.

Cons:

• The measurement units don’t follow the Singaporean teaching model; that is, they don’t thoroughly teach one type of measurement before moving on to the next, rather mixing US and metric together. This can cause confusion in students.
• For American teachers, teacher’s manual may be inadequate without further training.
• Doesn’t come with assessments; I used the Practices and Reviews in the textbook for this.
• Needs supplementation with math facts practice.
• Children going from this edition to public school may be missing some subjects, but stronger in others.
• Must be ordered online; shipping is high.

Overall: This is my preferred series despite its shortcomings, which can be easily overcome with a little knowhow and creativity.
Buy here: SingaporeMath.com, Inc.

Singapore Math, Standards Edition, published by Marshall-Cavendish:
This edition was created to meet the California learning standards. It is more colorful than the US Edition and covers slightly different topics each year. A comparison chart showing the scope and sequence of the two is available here. This series has been approved by the California State Board of Education.

Pros:

• Designed like the US Edition, with most of the same pros.
• Thorough Teacher’s Guide.
• Comes with Assessments.
• Decent Homeschooling Guide, from what I hear.

Cons: 

• One of the strengths of the Singapore Math curriculum is its focus on mastery of fewer subjects per year. This edition repeats the mistake of many US-designed curricula by putting in too many subjects per year so there is less time for each.
• Must be ordered online; shipping is high.

Overall: Recommended if the child is in California or the state has similar standards to meet.
Buy here: SingaporeMath.com, Inc.

Math in Focus, distributed by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt:
This series is new to the US market, and Houghton Mifflin has Americanized it, with the typical large-sized teacher guides, a variety of student books, and manipulatives, packaged in typical school bundles. I have seen the company at trade shows and looked at the materials there, and have requested samples, but none have been forthcoming, so I have not been able to test them out until now. I just discovered the online sampling website they provide, but it’s slow, and I can’t try it out with my students. So while I have been able to see the series to some extent, this review is less in depth than others.

Pros:

• Easiest for US public school teachers to adapt to, with explicit guides and scripts.
• Flows better to the middle school/high school Singapore curricula.
• Wide variety of differentiation options.

Cons:

• Expensive.
• Scores in Singapore went down after they implemented this program.
• Less emphasis on mental math.
• Books are larger with more complicated/busier graphics, potentially distracting from the learning process. I like the drawings, but combining them with photos can be confusing.

Overall: Recommended for teachers who don't have prior experience using Singapore Math. For those who do, I need more experience with this program to recommend it or not, but I would stick with the US Edition for now. Homeschooling parents are better off with one of the series from singaporemath.com.
Buy here: Greatsource.com

Singapore Math Practice, published by Frank Schaffer Publications:
This series appeared in bookstores a year or two ago, and I made a beeline to it with interest. I put it down almost immediately, though. It appears to capitalize on the popularity of Singapore Math without a thorough understanding of its best principles and practices.

Pros:

• Readily available in bookstores
• May provide extra practice in addition to using one of the other series, but use with caution.

Cons:

• Promotes the use of calculators too early, a big no-no in my book.
• Problems have mistakes and are not well designed.

Buy here: Amazon.com or in bookstores like Barnes & Noble

For more information and resources about Singapore Math, please visit my website. If you are interested in a local summer program implementing Singapore Math, please visit singaporemathny.com.