.
Feedback

Carvin: Shelly Silver Must Step Aside as Assembly Speaker

Rye Town Supervisor and Republican Congressional Candidate (NY-17th) Joe Carvin calls for Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver to resign leadership position for mishandling the Vito Lopez scandal.

CARVIN: SHELLY SILVER MUST STEP ASIDE AS SPEAKER 
---
Boxley and Lopez Cover-up Attempts Form an Unacceptable Pattern
--- 
We should have bi-partisan consensus that Mr. Silver must step aside as Speaker." 
 
Westchester-Rockland--Sept. 4...New York Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver (D-Manhattan), the longest-serving Speaker in state history, should resign his leadership role for mishandling the allegedly criminal sexual behavior of Assemblyman and Democratic Party boss Vito Lopez (D) against multiple female staff members. Mr. Silver helped arrange a secretive $103,000 pay out to some of the victims.  In 2008, Mr. Silver reportedly sought to hide from the public allegations of rape against his former legislative counsel Michael Boxley. 

 
"This is not the first time that the Speaker reportedly has worked behind closed doors to protect political colleagues from charges of sexual assault," Mr. Carvin said. "What allegedly took place to protect Mr. Silver's former counsel Michael Boxley from rape allegations was just as egregious. Mr. Silver has demonstrated a clear and unacceptable pattern of secrecy in these matters, and a stunning disregard for victims of sexual assault. This is unacceptable behavior from the third most powerful politician in state government.       Mr. Silver has served as Speaker since 1994. The  Assembly Speaker is selected by a vote of his Assembly colleagues.  "Mr. Silver  has served as Speaker capably for many years, and while I have disagreed with many of his policies, I have always respected his public service," Mr. Carvin continued. "But this latest controversy establishes a pattern of secrecy where transparency is most needed, necessitating his resignation as Speaker. At a time when we need to restore faith in our public leaders, this erodes the confidence of New York voters even more. In Washington and Albany, we need more transparency in government, not secretive arrangements like these. There must be consequences for elected leaders who act badly." Mr. Carvin, the father of two young daughters, spoke out last month against the controversial comments on rape made by Republican U.S. Senate candidate Todd Akin (R-Missouri). 

 "As public servants, we have a responsibility to speak out forcefully on matters of right and wrong, whether the transgressor is a Republican or Democrat," Mr. Carvin said." The real 'War on Women' is waged though silence when incidents like this are allowed to occur. I am hopeful that we can have a bi-partisan consensus in New York for Mr. Silver to step aside as Speaker." 

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Peekskill-Cortlandt Patch? Find your Local Patch »

tedc September 4, 2012 at 09:14 pm
"As public servants, we have a responsibility to speak out forcefully on matters of right and wrong, whether the transgressor is a Republican or Democrat," Mr. Carvin said.
Step aside? Where were Joe Carvin’s calls for Rye City’s Mayor French to “step aside” when his illegal rental house was uncovered - followed by his illegal double STAR tax exemptions being uncovered? Cup-O-Joe was and is; well, desperately and pathetically silent. Maybe ol Shelly Silver should be brought in front of a sham Ethics Committee – like we have in Rye City – stacked with campaign contributors and conflicted “advisors.” Democrats wouldn’t cheat in a closed door Executive Ethic’s Session now would they? http://www.lausdeo10580.com/lausdeo10580/2012/04/french-revolutionmayor-challenges-gop-leaders-rye-mayor-doug-french-was-has-been-caught-profiting-from-an-illegal-renta.html
HEALtheHARBOR.com September 4, 2012 at 09:48 pm
"There must be consequences for elected leaders who act badly"
Mr Carvin, Can you tell us what the consequences should be when our elected leader (Mayor Doug French) refuses to protect the Health and safety of the public? Please view the attached video and then respond. https://vimeo.com/47034186
jeff meyer September 5, 2012 at 01:19 am
I get it Mr. Carvin, Sheldon Silver and Todd Akin must go. I don't believe this is what you meant when you stated that you are running for Congress in the 17th District because tough decisions must be made. To criticize Sheldon Silver and Todd Akin is hardly a profile of courage . It is nice that you use the PATCH as a political forum but I must say that I am disappointed with you lack of specifics. Again sir, what are your specific ideas for federal debt reduction? Your view on Medicare? Social Security privatization? Medicare and SNAP reductions? Sequestration? The extension of the Bush tax cuts? How do you plan to cut the federal debt which you indicate is a main reason you wish to replace Rep. Lowey. You are obviously a person of ability and talent. However, your ambiguity and lack of specifics is rather lame to say the least. Jeff Meyer Tuckahoe,NY
Mike Hirsch September 5, 2012 at 02:40 am
Good luck with that idea Joe. Of course Sheldon Silver is bad for NY, but I don't see him stepping aside for anyone, including Governor Cuomo. I am happy to work on your election campaign. Because of the dysfunctional Rockland County GOP under Vinnie Reda, you're going to need help. If you would like to speak to our 1,000 member Clarkstown Taxpayer group, please get in touch.
Dick Hubert September 5, 2012 at 01:12 pm
The Carvin for Congress campaign wants to hear directly from all 17th Congressional District residents like Mike Hirsch who want to hold gatherings (large and small) where Joe Carvin can meet with you and your friends and colleagues to discuss the issues and where you can ask Joe directly how he will bring JOBS back to our residents, cut our federal debt, and bring economic well being back to the country. Just go to the campaign web site, WWW.CARVIN2012.COM, go to the "contacts" section, and communicate directly with the Carvin Team in Rockland or Westchester Counties to work out the details of time and place. And, oh yes, Joe's positions on the issues along with explanatory videos are on the web site. Even out of district Tuckahoe residents from Congressman Engel's 16th District are welcome to the site.
jeff meyer September 5, 2012 at 01:32 pm
Hi Dick. I am well aware of my district. However, if Mr. Carvin is going to continually use the Patch as a campaign forum then I will continually ask him for specifics. That is fair, isn't it? If he was running in my district you better believe I would have a "cup o joe" with him. Specifics and details Dick. PLEASE. Jeff Meyer Tuckahoe,NY
Mike Hirsch September 5, 2012 at 01:49 pm
Hi Dick, Our group is thinking of holding a Meet The Candidates night by inviting both Nita Lowey and Joe Carvin to speak in New City on October 29th. Is Joe interested?
Dick Hubert September 5, 2012 at 02:27 pm
For all Patch 17th Congressional District readers (including Mike Hirsch) interested in meeting with and hearing Joe Carvin in person, may I once again urge you to contact the campaign directly through Joe's web site, WWW.CARVIN2012.com. Give them your contact information, and the scheduling team will work with you to find a time that's convenient for all concerned. Thanks.
Tea Leaves September 7, 2012 at 01:31 pm
Yes, the Carvin campaign will happy to contact you as long as they can be reasonably sure you don't ask questions like this... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tAXc917yRo
Mike Hirsch September 7, 2012 at 01:47 pm
Dick, I have emailed the Carvin campaign folks a couple of times but have not heard back from them. Apparently Vinnie Reda, the Chairman of the dysfunctional Rockland County GOP, has told Carvin not to speak to our group of independent thinkers.
Tea Leaves September 7, 2012 at 02:02 pm
Maybe Mr. Carvin, who had liens placed on his property by New York State three of the last six years for failing to pay income taxes isn't the best guy to speak to a group of 1,000 (actual) taxpayers.
BG7 September 7, 2012 at 02:28 pm
Sheldon Silver - poster boy for the need for term limits in Albany.
jeff meyer September 7, 2012 at 10:50 pm
Tea Leaves, you have no right to comment on Mr. Carvin. You are not "credentialed media". LOL. JM Tuckahoe,NY
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
shakemdown June 19, 2013 at 12:03 am
@ASHLEY TARR my comments that i posted did not contain profanity nor did they harrass or abuseRead More anyone, they were just what the forum is for, to discuss issues within our city. but i know, some people would consider it harrasment or would try to have it deleted because the truth hurts,and that's what some of our elected officials don't want you to hear, (the truth)
shakemdown June 19, 2013 at 12:06 am
@jo you are right, the old web site was 100% better then this and it was more user friendly unlikeRead More this new one . BRING BACK THE OLD ONE
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 19, 2013 at 07:04 am
By the way, in our new system we have an update that includes a community moderation tool—it'sRead More not only Patch editors who can flag comments. What is it? Readers can flag any content they find objectionable on any Patch site at any time. We’ve put the flagging link in more places to make it easier to find and backed it with more sophisticated tools. Our goal is to recognize and reward readers who make our community great. How does it work? You’ll see these words — Flag as Inappropriate — on the top and bottom of Board posts, articles, blogs and notes, and next to every single comment anywhere on the site. To flag something, you simply click those words. What happens when you flag? It alerts us that something might be up with the content. When should you flag? We ask that you use your common sense and a general spirit of openness. You should never flag things that you simply disagree with and certainly not to clarify minor points. We encourage you to comment, post (or even start your own blog) to be heard on those things. You can review the Patch Terms of Use Ashley referred to above.
sue June 17, 2013 at 06:55 pm
they put them out bottom window to do their"business" right under several of our decks.Read More they are very rude and unhygenic.
sue June 17, 2013 at 07:00 pm
don't know why I'm having a problem getting this written............anyway...they are rude,Read More unhygenic and WILL NOT follow any of the condo rules....there's so much more but we are sick of it. There are only two of us that speak up...everyone else is cowering behind closed doors.
joshua tanner June 18, 2013 at 03:00 pm
Unleashed dogs is getting to be a big problem in Peekskill. I see them routinely now. People areRead More letting their pit bulls out, their poodles, their chihuahuas - all kinds of dogs. Two days a go I watched a lady jogging on the track with her loose dog. The dog wasn't even supposed to be on the track no less loose. Some kid or elderly lady is going to get bit. Loose dogs also end up in more fights with other dogs.
Nancy O'Connor June 17, 2013 at 09:33 am
It was our pleasure to help out....good food, good weather, all around good time!!
leesther brown June 18, 2013 at 11:48 am
@Nancy,,I Thanked both you and Pauline Ghilcrest for serving the community and they took my commentsRead More down twice!!! Once again Thank You..you're automatically signed up for next year..:)
joshua tanner June 15, 2013 at 10:28 pm
It seems Patch moves editors every year. Liz was here when I signed up. Then she was shortly movedRead More to Rye and Rasheed took over. He must have been here about a year and then he left when the new format was introduced. Both times patch started cooking and then it got cut down just as new staff got their mojo going. A new editor with a new format seems like starting from scratch again. I know AOL/Patch needs to get some cash flow going quick (from what I've read) but I can't see what they are trying to do exactly by tipping the cart over and over
Wendy Kelly June 17, 2013 at 08:37 am
Agree Joshua just when you have a good thing going with an Editor they move. I can't figure thisRead More site out I was not allowed to post for at least a week thought Mary et al put an hex on me. Hey anyone know where Peter Goodson is??? I miss his posts.
jo June 18, 2013 at 10:12 am
new format is a dud.. 100% dud.. not user friendly.. a horror to navigate, as mentioned... noRead More benefit here. not at all.. quickly becoming a ex Patch fan... fix the mess you made..
Wendy Kelly June 15, 2013 at 11:03 am
http://search.lohud.com/sp?aff=1100&skin=&keywords=revitalization of Peekskill
Working Families Party endorsed candidate Mary Foster
Robin Seggs June 14, 2013 at 10:44 am
Working Families Party almost always cross endorses with Democrats. Looks like the choice isRead More getting clearer: One team is Democrat, WFP and Independent and the Catalina Team is Republican, Right-to-life, Conservative. Anyway, I believe Catalina is campaigning as anti-gay rights, so I know how I will be voting.
jo June 14, 2013 at 02:28 pm
and so many in the cast of characters that attend the meetings. believe Mary is a republican atRead More heart.. and here the Left of all left dem groups endorses here..mmmmmmmm just thinking out loud..
stephanie June 14, 2013 at 03:57 pm
mary foster and the rest of her butt kissers not need to run after what they have done to this cityRead More already we don't need them to run another term they neeed to get out and stay out. i believe frank catalina will much better than foster will ever be he cares about the city and does not like what foster has done to this city i wish him very much luck and i truly believe he will win as our mayor for peekskill good luck and kick foster and her butt kissers out of city hall and keep them out
af24us June 12, 2013 at 01:48 pm
I agree - the dangerous stop signs On Hudson Ave should be removed in both directions and keep theRead More stop signs on South St. and the exit ramps from Route 9.
Master Nicholas Canaan and his Lodge Officers for the 2013-14 Masonic Year
Fly on the Wall June 9, 2013 at 08:49 pm
Great,..... Masons... send'em over to city hall to re-point the building. Lot's of loose bricks overRead More there.